New Jersey Chapter

Chapter Home


  • It's easier than ever to make a gift to the New Jersey Sierra Club by clicking on the "Donate" button. Your generous support today is a guaranteed investment in the future of our environment.

Newsletter -
Jersey Sierran

  • Click Here for the latest quarterly copy of the Sierra Club's publication on all things New Jersey.

Follow Us

Connect With Us:

Calendar Events

Apr 1 (Wed), 7:00 pm
Let's Talk Green
Apr 8 (Wed), 7:30 pm
Permaculture Design and Practices
Apr 8 (Wed), 7:30 pm
West Jersey Group General Meeting - Camden County Citizen Science Opportunities
Apr 8 (Wed), 7:30 pm
Sierra Silver Singles Planning Meeting
Apr 11 (Sat), 10:00 am
Singles Hike - Pyramid Mountain
Apr 11 (Sat), 10:00 am
Singles Hike - Garret Mountain and Great Falls
Apr 11 (Sat), 10:00 am
Black River Trail Hike
Apr 11 (Sat), 1:00 pm
Chapter Executive Committee meeting
Apr 14 (Tue), 7:00 pm
REBELS WITH A CAUSE - Documentary Film Screening
Apr 18 (Sat), 1:00 pm
Spring at Greenbrook

The New Jersey Chapter Web Site Has Moved!
This page will automatically redirect you in several seconds. Please update your bookmarks!

New url:

LSP Bill Unconstitutional, Environmentalists Call for Governor to Veto

Date : Wed, 8 Apr 2009 11:34:14 -0400

For Immediate Release
Contact: Jeff Tittel, Chapter Director

April 8, 2009
(609) 558-9100



LSP Bill Unconstitutional, Environmentalists Call for Governor to Veto


The Eastern Environmental Law Clinic has sent a letter to Governor Jon Corzine on behalf of the Sierra Club and the New Jersey Environmental Federation explaining why the LSP bill is unconstitutional. The letter went on to say that because the bill is unconstitutional, it has to be vetoed. The letter was hand delivered Saturday.


The LSP bill sets up a dangerous system for hazardous site cleanups. It delegates police powers to private individuals and limits state agencies from protecting public health, safety and property. It precludes the executive branch from enforcing the law.


"This bill is unconstitutional and unconscionable. It takes away the government's ability to protect us and instead protects the polluters," said Jeff Tittel, Director of the New Jersey Sierra Club.


Under this legislation, the DEP forfeits its authority to oversee cleanups of contaminated sites and to certify that they are clean. Instead, that authority will be delegated to private consultants that are hired by polluters and who have limited liability. This is a clear violation of the State Constitution's "Separation of Powers" clause because the constitution says it is unlawful to delegate to private parties functions of the state.


"This bill rejects case law, that's quite clear," said Dave Pringle, Campaign Director of the New Jersey Environmental Federation. "It's unconstitutional for the state to delegate police powers to private consultants on polluters' payrolls and prevent the AG from going after them when they've done wrong."


This legislation also impedes the state's ability to protect "Public Health and Safety" as set forth in the Constitution. The LSP law allows for these private consultants to deviate from state requirements on cleanups of hazardous materials. Because the state does not have proper oversight of these consultants, the Public Health and Safety Clause of the Constitution is violated. According to a 2006 report of the Massachusetts program, more than 70 percent of the contaminated sites had serious cleanup and reporting errors. More than half the sites had additional contaminated material on them.


This legislation also undermines the state's ability to exercise its authority of various state cleanup laws, such as ISRA and the Spill Act. It further limits the review of state agencies over these cleanups since it is the paid consultant that oversees, investigates, and certifies these toxic sites as being clean. The licensed site professional, who is paid by the polluter, certifies the cleanup work plan of the polluter. DEP will not be involved in certifying the cleanup work plan. Because of this, the law violations oversight and agency review and limits the agency's decision making capabilities.


The bill violates the "Separation of Powers" clause since decisions made by the LSP legally bind the state agencies to those decisions. It further violates the Separation of Powers because it provides the LSP with a covenant not to sue. Only the state's Attorney General can decide when and who to sue. These decisions by the LSP are final and limit "judicial review."


"This bill does not ensure adequate clean-up where kids live, learn and play and adequate safeguards against polluters who have a financial stake in doing the wrong thing," Pringle said. "If that's not reason enough to get the Governor to fix this bill, certainly complying with our constitution's separation of powers clause and prohibiting the delegation of police powers to protect public health and safety should be."


This legislation further takes away the "Right of Judicial" review not only for affected parties, but for the public or adjoining property owners. These concerned parties will have no ability to get a proper review or appeal the LSP decisions, whether to a commissioner, administrative law judge or any other body which you could under an NFA or a permit.


When Lisa Jackson was asked by Senator Barbara Boxer at her confirmation hearing, "Is the LSP program a program you would support nationally as head of EPA?", Lisa Jackson's answer was an emphatic 'no'.


"This bill violates the fundamental relationship between government and its citizens," Tittel said. "It is a radical departure from how government is supposed to work in order to protect public health and safety as well as the environment. Back in 1997, this legislation was rejected by Governor Whitman, Commissioner Shinn and the Republican State Senate. A bill that is this dangerous must be vetoed."



Kara Seymour, Program Assistant

NJ Sierra Club

145 W. Hanover Street

Trenton, NJ 08618


(f) 609.656.7618


Received on 2009-04-08 08:34:14

New Jersey Sierra Club, 145 West Hanover St., Trenton, NJ 08618, USA
tel: 609 656 7612, fax 609 656 7618
or email Nicole Dallara, Outreach Coordinator, at

Sierra Club is a registered trademark.
Questions and comments about this web site may be sent to: George Newsome

Page URL:
Page Last Modified 7/7/2014

Up to Top